Reading the Satyam Scam

“Earlier industrialists and then defence contracts financed political parties. Nowreal estate does, especially in the states because chief ministers have easier access to it. The kickbacks are huge” – CharlesCorrea (Interview, Times of India,10 September 2008). From "Maytas, Hyderabad Metro and the Politics of Real Estate" in the EPW which notes "In the 10 days since the revelation of the massive fraud at Satyam, there has been much speculation that the holes in the software company’s books were caused by the promoters’ links with Maytas, the infrastructure company that in recent years has become the favourite of the government of Andhra Pradesh. This article puts under the magnifying lens the award in 2008 of the massive Rs 12,000 crore contract to Maytas to build and operate the Hyderabad Metro."

Reading the Satyam Scam

Will the truth ever come out? What is this sham of corporate governance?

In a confession that led to his arrest and turmoil in corporate India, B Ramalinga Raju, the former chairman of Satyam Computer Services, India’s fourth largest information technology company, stated that he had manipulated accounts to inflate
revenues and profits. The result was a collapse in the value of the company’s stock and dissolution of its board. Raju’s confessionessentially stated that having doctored the firm’s accounts formany years, he was left with hugely overstated cash reserves and understated liabilities that amounted to a shortfall of more than Rs 7,000 crore in the company’s balance sheet. This was impossibleto fill without the infusion of resources from outside. When his effort to get Satyam to “takeover” two companies owned by his family – Maytas Properties and Maytas Infra – in order to fill this
hole with real assets failed because of shareholder resistance, he decided to reveal the fraud.

There could be many explanations for why this high profile company in an industry that has reported consistently strong revenue growth, export expansion and profitability, and is supported by the State with special tax benefits, chose to inflate profits that must have already been favourable by overall industry
standards. One allegation that has surfaced is that this was part of an effort to inflate stock values and the wealth of the promoters. Another allegation that is reportedly being investigated is that the manipulation of accounts followed the siphoning of resources from the company to expand the wealth of promoters, who had a relatively small and declining shareholding in Satyam. Speculation aside, the actual details of what transpired at Satyam Computer Services prior to the confession will
emerge only after much time, if at all they will.

One problem is that it is difficult to accept the former chairman’sconfession at face value, because it implicitly suggests that Satyam was performing much worse than other leading IT companies. Satyam was undertaking activities similar to these companies and like them had leading Fortune 500 companies among its clients. Its billing and its costs could not have been very different. So it does not seem surprising that the audited balance sheet of the company showed that the ratio of profits before tax to total income in Satyam in the financial year ending March 2008 was 27.8%, as compared with 32.3% in the case of Infosys, 23.1% in TCS, 23.1 and 19.2% in the case of Wipro. Yet
we are being told to believe that Satyam’s profit figureswere hugely exaggerated leading to the gaping hole in its balance sheet.

The big question is to what extent the Satyam scam is linked to the explosive growth under the current Congress ruled government of Andhra Pradesh of the Maytas companies, which have emerged as the favoured contractors of the state government and have bagged projects worth over Rs 30,000 crore in irrigation, ports, and the Hyderabad Metro. While Satyam was projected by the previous Telugu Desam Party government in Andhra Pradesh as well, there is no question that Maytas has become what it is
during the Congress regime. Since the award of large government contracts almost always involves payoffs, the moot question is how much of the hole in Satyam was created by the extraction of resources to fuel Maytas’ growth. As the detailed discussion in the article on Hyderabad Metro elsewhere in this issue reveals,
there is much to suspect in the favours showered on Maytas. The Satyam trail then would lead to the mainstream political parties and the incentive to hush up the story will be strong.

Whatever the actual scam, an issue that needs examining is why conventional monitoring and disciplining mechanisms failed in this case, permitting accounting fraud over a long period. To start with, this huge fraud, which also involved declaring cash
reserves that did not exist, was completely missed by a high profile board, which even agreed to allow the promoters to use these nonexistent reserves to buy two unrelated companies in which the latter have a major stake. The board included distinguished
independent directors, who, according to reports, were being paid huge fees for their professional services. This gives rise to the criticism that the practice of managements paying independent directors could lead them to take a “soft” view of matters and nottake their monitoring role seriously. Given the fact that the board
of directors is the institutional form through which the top management is disciplined, especially in a firm like Satyam, where there are a large number of investors other than the promoters who collectively own a very large share of equity but individually do not have an influential holding, the board ought to have exercised
its functions, vis-a-vis the top management, the promoters, and the other shareholders, in the best tradition of business ethics. There is reason to believe that it failed in this respect.

A related failure was the inability of the firm’s auditors, Price Waterhouse Coopers, one of the big four, to detect manipulation of this magnitude. As has been noted, the search for large fee incomes and the competition between auditors to increase market share results in a situation where auditors take the claims of their large clients and the documents they produce at face value and do not carry out the minimal checks which would possibly have revealed the fraud at Satyam, whatever it may be. Here again, the fact that the monitor is paid by the monitored seems to be a major source of the problem.

Hence, these and other failures of the regulatory mechanism need to be investigated as well. It must lead to comprehensive reform that ensures that we do not have other Satyams because of the weaknesses of the institutional and regulatory environment.

Economic & Political Weekly EPW january 17, 2009


Anonymous said…
[b][url=]ugg boots uk[/url][/b] You may get a cost-free pizza only for sharing your working experience and taking notes about wait time, maintain time etcetera. We a short while ago ate at IHOP without spending a dime. The questionnaire took about ten minutes to fill out. Take a look at your complete alternatives guarantee you seek out a case for you personally to love. Created outside of vital Initialed or monogrammed cloth, it attributes 1 outer zipped wallet permitting easy accessibility to vital objects. That may be undoubtedly easy to catch requirement from making use of it investing voyage and common meeting..

[b][url=]uggs[/url][/b] four. Long-lasting lipstick: From feeding on to kissing, your lipstick has lots of possibilities to fade or smear absent. Before deciding on a person brand name or shade, check out it out for awhile. That which you require is just a computer along with a mouse. Then, you may surf the net. Test to seek out tiffany bracelet outlets to the site.

[b][url=]louis vuitton bags[/url][/b] Jungian psychotherapy can be a wealthy expertise with a lot of faces. Even so, the process of understanding Jung and his thoughts can frequently times be a challenging a single. From the month-to-month content that stick to, I will endeavor to introduce some of the fundamental tenets of Jungian assessment and psychotherapy.

[b][url=]uggs boots[/url][/b] Consequently relaxation room I actually stick to this printer nail artwork do the job. Which have been latest had been shocked as a consequence of the methods about Betty Birkin. You truly approve so that you can apperceive aboriginal be it for the purpose of most vital or normally not.

[b][url=]ugg boots outlet[/url][/b] Now, a important concern is, "is it feasible for your lower/average members of your culture to personal a Louis Vuitton product or service?" nicely, however, the solution to this problem is not any; Louis Vuitton has never violated its pricing and high quality insurance policies and except the reasonably very low salary earners or regular class of the modern society will get rich and find a way to manage LV solutions, they could hardly ever obtain them. Essentially, there is absolutely no low-priced Louis Vuitton merchandise. Having said that, becoming a happy owner of LV products has stopped staying an distinctive patent with the affluent; in case you genuinely necessarily mean to get an LV item, you can realize this kind of target.
Anonymous said…
[url=]ugg sale[/url]
on [url=][/url]
Anonymous said…
[b][url=][/url][/b] Apart from her well-known mom and good grandfather, Lydia designed her largest mark in the globe of modeling. Magazine encompasses, catwalks and various ad campaigns make up a sizable part of her modeling resume. Lydia has the kind of search that has enabled her to nearly do it all while in the modeling entire world..

[b][url=]louis vuitton purses[/url][/b] To save lots of hard cash regarding this vital allocation get abiding for you personally to boutiqueonline to stop wasting which will abounding uncovered money. Persons just no best settle for lead to theabode to help you to retail outlet any time you can retailer together with enable you to help you save on the web for your merchandise. Making over the internet getting from ebay could acquiesce you to pay for cutting edge orhardly acclimated components for a large amount of a minimal level of.

[b][url=]louis vuitton outlet[/url][/b] Louis Vuitton Cream Briefcase Completes Your Prince CharmingMan, really don't at any time consider white luster for feminine legal rights. She doesn't let you know what collaboration she even further expects you to build alongside one another with her. Which is, when she eventually receives her coveted white Chanel allure, she can stand apart from you, her prince charming whose white briefcase is accomplishing a glam concerto with her white Chanel purse.

[b][url=]uggs australia[/url][/b] In lawful estate on the most prestigious do the job of your judge (specifically federal, over a lifelong post) is recognized as; a little bit a lot more very low, in the point of view of cultural status, lawyers of organizations and lawyers-scientists (the professor of the suitable) calm down; even more there are actually the attorneys doing work in administrative departments, and workforce state solutions. The team of lawyers-politicians costs independently. Its "cumulative" status is calculated by political achievement in the independent figures that have achieved of heights within the state and also the politician..

[b][url=]ugg boots uk[/url][/b] You will need to have a very appropriate attitude to get started on making dollars on line. A right frame of mind is like a magnet attracting the "internet money". You should use a steady understanding frame of mind. In the World's Fairs in 1867 with each other with 1889, Louis Vuitton attained to start with a bronze along with a gold medal in recognition inside the excellence of his bags. Nonetheless it was not until 1892 that to start with Louis Vuitton purses hit the marketplace. Quickly soon after the Louis Vuitton Company's necessities line grew more substantial alongside one another with greater.
Anonymous said…
Its like you learn my mind! You seem to grasp a lot approximately this, like
you wrote the e-book in it or something. I feel that you can do with
some % to drive the message house a bit, but other than that, that is great blog. An excellent read. I'll definitely be back.

Have a look at my blog post cleaning services phoenix
Also see my web site - cleaning services phoenix
Anonymous said…
Hi there, i read your blog occasionally and i own
a similar one and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam remarks?
If so how do you reduce it, any plugin or anything you can advise?
I get so much lately it's driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated.

my web blog - cleaning service phoenix
My page :: phoenix maid service
Anonymous said…
We're a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community. Your web site provided us with valuable information to work on. You have done a formidable job and our entire community will be thankful to you.
hardwood floors

my blog: engineered hardwood flooring

Popular posts from this blog

Cover-up Commissions

Public Statement on Prashant Bhushan's contempt case

Obama Administration Releasing New Rules To Expand Ability To Hold Citizens' Data